‘Goldilocks’ treatment window could lead to cancer therapy without harmful side-effects

21 June 2022
Key Researchers
Laboratory Head
Division Head
Senior Research Officer
Researchers have developed a way to potentially reduce the toxic side-effects of a type of immunotherapy, in findings that could overcome the pioneering treatment’s biggest limitation.

At a glance

  • Australian-Israeli research team develop a way to fine-tune CAR T cell immunotherapy treatments to reduce their toxic side effects

  • About 50% of patients experience harmful complications from immunotherapy.

  • The findings could overcome this significant barrier by tailoring the immune cells used in the treatment to prevent toxic side-effects.

CAR T cell therapy is a new form of immunotherapy that enhances a patient’s killer immune cells to attack and eliminate cancer.

 Dr Ashleigh Davey, Associate Professor Matthew Call, Associate Professor Melissa Call, Dr Nick Chandler.
L-R: Dr Ashleigh Davey, Associate Professor Matthew Call,
Associate Professor Melissa Call, Dr Nick Chandler. 

It can be up to 90% effective in certain blood cancers and can even deliver long-term remissions and cures in some patients. But a significant limitation is the treatment’s harmful side-effects, with about 50% of patients experiencing dangerous complications. 

The new study, led jointly by WEHI researchers in collaboration with Israel’s Weizmann Institute of Science, has designed a way to identify a ‘goldilocks’ window that strikes a balance of safety and efficacy.

The team’s approach finetunes the cells used in the immunotherapy so that their activity is strong enough to eliminate the cancer but not so strong that they generate toxic side-effects.

The findings, led by WEHI’s Associate Professor Matthew Call and Associate Professor Melissa Call, are published in eLife.

Crucial redesign

CAR T cell therapies involve collecting T cells from a cancer patient and supercharging the cells by individually re-engineering them in the laboratory. These enhanced cells are then put back into patients.

The T cells are engineered to produce proteins on their surface called chimeric antigenreceptors (CARs), which act as artificial sensors that enable T cells to recognise and bind to specific proteins on the surface of cancer cells more efficiently.

Associate Professor Matthew Call said this synthetic sensor is what gives T cells the enhanced ability to attack and eliminate threats, like cancer cells.

“While putting these supercharged T cells into a patient with a high tumour burden can swiftly eradicate cancer cells, it also creates the perfect storm for an ongoing toxic response that can be harmful,” Associate Professor Call said.

There is currently no way of reliably predicting how strong CAR T cell therapy will be for a patient.

While previous studies have attempted to fine-tune T cells by targeting the end sections of the sensor, which either bind to the cancer cell or instruct the T cells to kill, the new research is the first to look at completely redesigning the middle part.

Researchers leveraged the computational expertise of the Weizmann Institute of Science to stitch together pieces of natural immune sensors with custom-designed synthetic elements, to generate new circuits that could be used to tune and assess variations of potency.

“Focusing on the connector fragment in the middle allows us to generate different versions of CARs that we know are stronger or weaker, enabling us to customise them to a patient’s potency requirements,” Associate Professor Call said.

“Being able to predictably tune this T cell activity significantly broadens our research, contrary to previous studies, because we are targeting something that exists in every immunotherapy scenario. 

“For the first time, we can establish rules that will be applicable to any cancer where CAR T cell immunotherapy is being used.”

Enhanced treatment  

Associate Professor Melissa Call said the ability to fine-tune T cells would dramatically reduce the number of patients experiencing severe side-effects from the treatment, which can include fever, high blood pressure and respiratory distress.

“CAR T cell therapy has proven effective in eradicating very advanced leukemias and lymphomas, while also keeping the cancer at bay for many years – even after a patient has stopped taking cancer medication,” Associate Professor Call said.

“The therapy has incredible potential for cancer patients, but is currently used as a last resort due to these potentially severe side-effects.


A healthy human T cell. Re-eingineered T cells
are put back into a patient during CAR T cell therapy. 
Credit: National Cancer Institute (NCI) 

“Our tools could lead to a fundamental rethink of the way CAR T cell therapy is offered by reducing a patient’s exposure risk to harmful side-effects. This would allow patients with a broad range of cancers to be given CAR T cell therapy far earlier in the treatment process.”

There are currently over 600 clinical trials of CAR T cell immunotherapy, with the treatment already being used for several blood cancers.

Researchers hope their new tool could be used to triage immunotherapy patients based on the level of potency they require in early phases of their treatment and bring the field closer to striking that ‘goldilocks’ treatment window for many different cancers.

The next research phase, supported by the NHMRC, the Leukaemia Foundation, Cancer Australia and Hearts and Minds Investments Ltd and TDM Foundation will focus on progressing these findings into a clinical setting to see CAR T cell therapy used as a safer, first-line treatment.

The research, with first authors Dr Nicholas Chandler and Dr Ashleigh Davey, was supported by the NHMRC, the European Research Council, the Harry Secomb Foundation, the Percy Baxter Charitable Trust and the Harold and Cora Brennen Benevolent Trust.

WEHI authors: Nicholas Chandler, Ashleigh Davey, Julie Nguyen, Raphael Trenker, Ryan Cross, Misty Jenkins, Melissa Call, Matthew Call.

DOI: 10.7554/eLife.75660

Media enquiries

M: +61 475 751 811

E: communications@wehi.edu.au

WEHI Authors
Laboratory Head
Division Head
Senior Research Officer
Support us

Together we can create a brighter future

Your support will help WEHI’s researchers make discoveries and find treatments to ensure healthier, longer lives for you and your loved ones.

Sign up to our quarterly newsletter Illuminate

Find out about recent discoveries, community supporters and more.

Illuminate Autumn 2024
View the current issue